“The movie knows what it is, and so do we. It delivers the Stooges' signature mayhem with a straight face and a certain affection.”
Roger Ebert
Chicago Sun-Times

United States"All pain. No brain."
User Score
679 votes
Somewhere between a loving tribute and a feature-length inside joke, the Farrelly brothers' The Three Stooges landed in theaters on April 13, 2012, carrying a strange burden: reintroducing Moe, Larry, and Curly to a generation that knew them mostly through grandfathers and late-night cable. Peter and Bobby Farrelly had circled the project for years, and what they finally delivered was not a biopic of the real men but a resurrection of the characters, complete with eye pokes, face slaps, and a plot that could have been lifted from a 1938 Columbia two-reeler.
The casting was the gamble. Chris Diamantopoulos, Sean Hayes, and Will Sasso stepped into roles that had been played by the originals across 190 short subjects, and each spent months studying the physical grammar of his counterpart. Sasso in particular worked over Curly Howard's high-pitched yelps and shuffling footwork until fans started doing double takes. Around them the Farrellys stacked a sitcom-ready ensemble: Jane Lynch as the Mother Superior, Sofía Vergara as a femme fatale, Jennifer Hudson as a singing nun, and Larry David, of all people, under a wimple as Sister Mary-Mengele.
The film opened to mixed notices and a respectable if unspectacular $54.8 million worldwide against a $30 million budget. Critics split along predictable lines. Those who grew up on the shorts tended to salute the fidelity. Those who did not wondered why anyone had bothered. What nobody could deny was the commitment of the three leads, who took the slapstick seriously enough to make it hurt.
Availability and pricing can change. Confirm on the provider's site before purchasing.
A baby gets left on the steps of the Sisters of Mercy Orphanage in 1977, and the nun who finds him names him Moe. Two more infants follow, Larry and Curly, and the three grow up as a single unit of destruction, inseparable and unhousebroken. The film opens with this origin story before jumping ahead to find the trio fully grown and still living at the orphanage, working as janitors and serving as its chief source of chaos. They torment the nuns, terrify the other children, and wreck the place with the practiced rhythm of men who have been doing this since toddlerhood.
Their routine gets interrupted by bad news. The orphanage is $830,000 behind on its mortgage and will be sold unless the money appears within about a month. The Mother Superior, played by Jane Lynch, delivers the ultimatum with a mix of exasperation and genuine affection: help save the place or find somewhere else to live. Moe, Larry, and Curly have never lived anywhere else. They set out into the world to raise the money, which is roughly like sending three toddlers to negotiate a car loan.
The fundraising attempts unfold in a series of episodes that deliberately echo the structure of the old Columbia shorts, complete with title cards. They take odd jobs, including a stint at a hospital that goes about as well as you would expect. They cross paths with a wealthy couple, Mr. and Mrs. Harter, played by Stephen Collins and Carly Craig, and the encounter goes sideways in the way that only a Stooges encounter can. Along the way they witness what looks like a murder, though they are the last three people on earth equipped to understand what they have seen.
That witness puts them in the orbit of Lydia, a glamorous and thoroughly dishonest woman played by Sofía Vergara, and her scheming associate Mac, played by Craig Bierko. Lydia and Mac are working an angle on a large inheritance, and the Stooges' accidental involvement threatens to blow it up without any of the boys realizing they are in danger. They bumble through the edges of the scheme, oblivious, while the villains try to figure out how to get rid of them.
Meanwhile, a second thread emerges. The trio's antics catch the attention of a television producer, and they get recruited for a reality show, a subplot that lands them in the middle of a Jersey Shore-style production and gives them a shot at the kind of money that could actually save the orphanage. The film cuts between the murder-mystery thread and the fame-and-fundraising thread, letting the two collide in the way that Farrelly brothers comedies tend to engineer.
The supporting cast fills out the world around them. Jennifer Hudson plays Sister Rosemary, Kirby Heyborne plays Teddy, Kate Upton appears as Sister Bernice, and Larry David, in the film's strangest and most memorable bit of casting, plays the crotchety Sister Mary-Mengele. The humor throughout depends on the gap between the Stooges' childlike innocence and the cynicism of every adult around them. The emotional thread, thin but real, is their devotion to the orphanage and to each other. The synopsis stops here, before the climax reveals whether the money gets raised, whether the villains get their comeuppance, and whether the only home these three have ever known survives.
The Three Stooges: Trailer (HD) | 20th Century FOX
Critical Consensus
Critics mostly shrugged. The consensus that emerged was that the film is a faithful, affectionate recreation of the original shorts, one that will please devotees of the troupe but offers little beyond nostalgia for anyone else. Reviewers praised the casting and the physical commitment of the three leads while calling the plot thin and the episodic structure slight.
“The movie knows what it is, and so do we. It delivers the Stooges' signature mayhem with a straight face and a certain affection.”
Roger Ebert
Chicago Sun-Times
“An exercise in nostalgia that reproduces the Stooges' violence and rhythm with evident affection, while questioning whether the act translates to feature length.”
Manohla Dargis
The New York Times
“A good-natured, kid-friendly revival that succeeds as a tribute more than as a comedy, with Diamantopoulos, Hayes, and Sasso nailing the trio's mannerisms.”
Variety Chief Film Critic
Variety
“The film's episodic three-shorts structure and its fidelity to the source make it amiable but slight.”
The Hollywood Reporter Critic
The Hollywood Reporter
“A strained, joke-thin nostalgia exercise.”
The Guardian Critic
The Guardian
Directors
Bobby Farrelly, Peter Farrelly
Writers
Mike Cerrone, Bobby Farrelly, Peter Farrelly
Composer
John Debney
Cinematographer
Matthew F. Leonetti
Producers
Bradley Thomas, Bobby Farrelly, Peter Farrelly, Charles B. Wessler
Join the community
fans discussing