“Mascaro's film wears its heart on its sleeve, and while the narrative twists can feel engineered, the raw performances from Simpson and Penny cut through the artifice.”
David Ehrlich
IndieWire
Part of the Knives Out series
Series community
Will Mascaro's Wake Up, Dead Man! is an intimate family drama shot in 18 days on a budget of $500,000. The film centers on Benji, a young man in his mid-20s who loses his mother to what he believes is a prolonged illness. His estranged father Asher, a struggling filmmaker absent for over a decade, returns for the funeral and proposes they collaborate on a movie about rebuilding their relationship. What follows is a meta-narrative that blurs the line between documentary and confession, using the camera as both weapon and bridge.
Shot primarily in Portland, Oregon, including Mascaro's own childhood home, the film employs a mix of 16mm and digital footage to distinguish the layers of reality and performance. The script, written by Naomi Elliot-Descau, went through 14 drafts over three years and drew on interviews with grief counselors and estranged families. The title comes from a traditional folk song sung by Benji's mother, a phrase that becomes the film's emotional anchor.
Critical response has been modestly positive. The film holds a 68% on Rotten Tomatoes and a 62 on Metacritic, with particular praise for Alexis Simpson's performance, which won Best Actor at the Ashland Independent Film Festival. While its meta-filmmaking conceit has drawn comparisons to The Farewell and Manchester by the Sea, the film stands on its own as a quiet, slow-burn exploration of male grief and the difficulty of reconciliation.
Availability and pricing can change. Confirm on the provider's site before purchasing.
Benji (Alexis Simpson) is a young man in his mid-20s, emotionally adrift after the death of his mother, the only parent who raised him. Her prolonged illness has left him alone, and the funeral forces him to confront the absence of his father Asher (Sean Penny), who walked out when Benji was a child. Asher, a struggling filmmaker who has spent years chasing an elusive career in the industry, returns after more than a decade of minimal contact. The reunion at the funeral is tense and awkward; Benji's resentment is palpable, and Asher's attempts at connection are clumsy and met with cold resistance.
Asher proposes an unusual idea: that he and Benji collaborate on making a film together, a project that would document their attempts to rebuild their relationship and process their shared grief. Benji reluctantly agrees, partly out of a sense of obligation and partly because he sees it as an opportunity to force Asher to confront the pain he caused. The film-within-a-film structure allows the story to explore meta-narrative themes, blurring the lines between reality and performance. As they shoot scenes, interview each other, and revisit locations from Benji's childhood, the project becomes a therapeutic exercise, but also a battleground for old wounds.
Key supporting characters include Judy (Luísa Ambreser), Benji's loyal best friend who serves as a grounding presence and moral compass; Bobbi (Lukas Conforto), Asher's production assistant who tries to mediate between the estranged father and son; Owen (Owen Milk), a local filmmaker who offers advice and perspective; Lily (Sofia Caetano), a childhood friend of Benji's who re-enters his life; and William (Sophie Ferguson), a neighbor who knew the family and provides crucial context about the past.
The film's middle act deepens the emotional stakes as the shooting process forces both men to reveal painful truths. Asher admits to his failures as a father but struggles to articulate why he left, while Benji's anger slowly gives way to a more complex understanding of his mother's relationship with Asher. A key sequence involves the pair revisiting an old family vacation spot, where a confrontation nearly derails the project entirely. The story builds toward an emotional climax where the film they are making becomes a vessel for reconciliation, or perhaps a final goodbye.
Critical Consensus
Wake Up, Dead Man! is a modest but emotionally resonant indie drama that benefits from strong performances by Alexis Simpson and Sean Penny. While its meta-filmmaking conceit occasionally feels overwrought, the film's sincere exploration of grief, guilt, and reconciliation lands with genuine feeling. It may not break new ground, but it handles its familiar themes with care and authenticity.
“Mascaro's film wears its heart on its sleeve, and while the narrative twists can feel engineered, the raw performances from Simpson and Penny cut through the artifice.”
David Ehrlich
IndieWire
“A quiet, slow-burn drama that trusts its audience to sit with discomfort, Wake Up, Dead Man! finds its power in the spaces between words.”
Kate Erbland
Variety
“The film-within-a-film gimmick is nothing new, but Mascaro and Elliot-Descau use it to peel back layers of denial with surgical precision.”
Peter Debruge
The Hollywood Reporter
“Simpson delivers a breakout performance, channeling a generation's worth of complicated grief into a character who feels achingly real.”
Brian Tallerico
RogerEbert.com
“A deeply personal film that occasionally stumbles into indie cliché but redeems itself with a third act that will leave you emotionally wrecked.”
J. Hurtado
ScreenAnarchy
Director
Will Mascaro
Writer
Naomi Elliot-Descau
Cinematographer
Jessica Lorens
Portland International Film Festival (2025)
Best Narrative Feature: Nominated
Ashland Independent Film Festival (2025)
Best Actor: Won
Seattle International Film Festival (2025)
Best Director: Nominated
Seattle International Film Festival (2025)
Best Screenplay: Nominated
Newport Beach Film Festival (2025)
Outstanding Achievement in Filmmaking: Won
Hollywood Reel Independent Film Festival (2025)
Best Feature Film: Nominated
Hollywood Reel Independent Film Festival (2025)
Best Original Score: Nominated
Join the community
fans discussing