“The shore-bound romance is the film's weakest element, dragging a remarkable sea story into conventional melodrama that never quite earns its place.”
Andrew Wright
The Stranger
On the night of February 18, 1952, a nor'easter off Cape Cod split the T-2 oil tanker SS Pendleton in two. The stern half stayed afloat with more than thirty men aboard, and the only vessel close enough to help was a 36-foot wooden Coast Guard lifeboat crewed by four men who had been ordered out into seas that could swallow them. The Finest Hours dramatizes that rescue, still the most decorated small-boat operation in Coast Guard history.
Craig Gillespie directed from a screenplay by Scott Silver, Paul Tamasy, and Eric Johnson, with Casey Sherman adapting the 2009 nonfiction book he wrote with Michael J. Tougias. Chris Pine plays Bernie Webber, the boatswain's mate still carrying the weight of an earlier failed rescue. Casey Affleck is Ray Sybert, the Pendleton's reserved engineer who keeps the stern from going under. Ben Foster, Eric Bana, and Holliday Grainger fill out the principal cast as crewmate Richard Livesey, station commander Daniel Cluff, and Webber's fiancee Miriam.
Walt Disney Pictures released the film on January 29, 2016, after a January 27 premiere. It cost a reported $80 million and returned about $52.1 million worldwide, a gap wide enough that the studio reportedly expected a loss near $75 million. Reviews were mixed: critics credited the practical storm work and the two leads, while faulting a screenplay that leaned on convention. The picture has since settled into a quieter life on Disney+ and in maritime-history circles, where the 1952 event itself still draws more attention than the film made from it.
Availability and pricing can change. Confirm on the provider's site before purchasing.
Chatham, Massachusetts, in the winter of 1951 and 1952. The local Coast Guard station is a small, weathered building staffed by men from the surrounding towns, and the work is less glamorous than the uniform suggests. Bernie Webber (Chris Pine) is a boatswain's mate who follows the rulebook and speaks softly, and he is still living down a rescue attempt that went wrong months earlier. The failure has made him careful, and some of the men he serves with read that care as timidity.
His courtship of Miriam (Holliday Grainger), a telephone operator, gives the film its landward thread. She is direct about wanting marriage. He hesitates, partly out of temperament and partly because he does not think much of himself as a prospect. The two of them navigate the small rituals of early-1950s New England courtship, and the film treats their engagement as the personal stake that will matter once the weather turns.
Out on the water, the tanker SS Pendleton is making its run with a crew of seasoned merchant mariners. Ray Sybert (Casey Affleck) serves as the ship's engineer, a man more at ease with machinery than with the men who operate it. He is competent and respected in a technical sense, but he is not liked, and he seems to prefer it that way. The Pendleton is a T-2 tanker, a wartime design now hauling oil in civilian service, and its hull has been taking a pounding.
The nor'easter arrives in the early hours of February 18. The Pendleton's hull fails amidships and the ship breaks in two. The bow section drifts away with most of the officers. The stern, carrying more than thirty men, is left without power, without reliable radio contact, and with water coming in. Sybert, almost by default, becomes the man in charge. He uses his knowledge of the ship's ballast and pumps to keep the stern upright, improvising as equipment fails and as the crew's discipline wears thinner with each hour.
At the Chatham station, commander Daniel Cluff (Eric Bana) makes the call to send a boat out. The conditions are as bad as the station has seen: hurricane-force wind, snow that cuts visibility to nothing, and seas breaking across the Chatham Bar, a sandbar notorious for capsizing vessels that try to cross it. Bernie is assigned to take a four-man crew out in a 36-foot wooden motor lifeboat, a craft built for calmer water. His crew includes Richard Livesey (Ben Foster), a blunt and skeptical seaman who makes no secret of doubting Bernie after the earlier failure, along with Andy Fitzgerald (Kyle Gallner) and Ervin Maske (John Magaro).
The crossing is brutal. The boat is tossed and nearly rolled, the compass will not hold a heading, and navigation is done by dead reckoning and guesswork. The film cuts between the lifeboat, the Pendleton's stern, and the shore, where Miriam and the townspeople wait with nothing to do but listen to the storm on the radio and imagine the worst.
The story's tension comes from two directions. There is the obvious contest between men and weather, as two groups fight a sea that seems determined to kill them. And there is the quieter contest inside Bernie, who has to overcome his own doubt and the open doubt of his crew to carry out a mission that most of the men involved privately expect to fail. The dramatic question is simple: can the small boat and the broken tanker find each other in a black, snow-blind sea before the stern goes under? The film builds toward that meeting and stops there, leaving the rescue itself for the final act.
Disney's The Finest Hours | Official Trailer
Critical Consensus
Reviewers generally respected the committed performances and the practical storm sequences, but found the screenplay bound to formula. The land-based romance drew the sharpest complaints for slowing the film down. Most agreed it was a well-made but conventional Disney disaster picture that never quite matched the extraordinary true story behind it.
“The shore-bound romance is the film's weakest element, dragging a remarkable sea story into conventional melodrama that never quite earns its place.”
Andrew Wright
The Stranger
“The movie leans on cliché when the genuinely extraordinary true story would have been more than enough on its own.”
MaryAnn Johanson
FlickFilosopher
“The real 1952 rescue was more astonishing than anything the film's dramatization attempts, which makes the picture's caution all the more frustrating.”
Time staff
Time
“The four-man crew's feat remains the Coast Guard's most celebrated small-boat rescue, a fact the film treats with respect even when the script does not rise to it.”
Coast Guard Foundation
Coast Guard Foundation
Director
Craig Gillespie
Writers
Scott Silver, Paul Tamasy, Eric Johnson, Casey Sherman, Michael J. Tougias
Composer
Carter Burwell
Cinematographer
Javier Aguirresarobe
Producers
Dorothy Aufiero, Jim Whitaker
Join the community
fans discussing