Last updated
    Three Identical Strangers
    🎬movieReleasedPG-13

    Three Identical Strangers

    United Kingdom flagUnited Kingdom

    "Three brothers. One secret. A life built on lies."

    2018 97 English
    79%

    User Score

    145000 votes

    Community

    Overview

    New York City, 1980. Three nineteen-year-old men living completely separate lives stumble upon a shocking truth: they are identical triplets separated at birth. Their accidental reunion sparks a media frenzy that turns these strangers into international celebrities overnight. Director Tim Wardle captures this whirlwind in the documentary Three Identical Strangers, blending the initial joy of discovery with an underlying sense of dread.

    The film features the triplets themselves, David Kellman, Robert Shafran, and Eddy Galland, playing versions of their real selves as they navigate sudden fame and the unraveling of a hidden past. What begins as a heartwarming tale of destiny quickly transforms into a chilling investigation into the ethics of human experimentation. The documentary relies heavily on archival footage and intimate interviews to expose a conspiracy that lasted decades.

    Where to Watch

    Availability and pricing can change. Confirm on the provider's site before purchasing.

    PlotSpoiler-free

    In the summer of 1980, New York City becomes the unlikely setting for a story that would captivate the world. Bobby Shafran, an 18-year-old college student from a working-class Jewish family in Queens, and Eddy Galland, a similar-aged young man raised by a wealthy, secular family in Brooklyn, meet by pure coincidence on a street corner. They immediately recognize each other as identical twins. Their shared resemblance is so striking that they cannot believe they are not brothers until they confirm their birth dates and physical traits match perfectly. Soon after, they discover a third identical male, David Kellman, who was raised by a conservative, religious family in Long Island. The three men, now dubbed "the triplets," realize they were separated at birth and adopted into three vastly different socioeconomic and cultural environments.

    The film documents the whirlwind that ensues as the triplets decide to reunite. Initially hesitant due to the shock of the discovery, they eventually agree to meet, sparking an instant media frenzy. News outlets from around the globe descend upon them, turning the accidental meeting into a global sensation. The triplets become international celebrities, appearing on television talk shows, magazine covers, and in newsreels. Their bond is immediate and profound; they share a unique telepathic connection, finishing each other's sentences and moving in perfect sync. The documentary captures their initial joy, the thrill of fame, and the strange new dynamic of living three separate lives while sharing a single genetic blueprint.

    As the triplets navigate their sudden fame, they begin to notice subtle but unsettling similarities in their behaviors, habits, and even health issues, despite being raised apart. They are interviewed extensively about their experiences, discussing how nature versus nurture plays out in their lives. However, a sense of unease begins to permeate the narrative. While the public sees a heartwarming tale of destiny and brotherhood, the triplets themselves start to feel a growing pressure. They are constantly asked about their adoption, their families, and the scientific implications of their existence. The film slowly shifts tone from a lighthearted celebration of coincidence to a psychological thriller. The triplets' increasing isolation, the intense scrutiny from the media, and the strange questions they are forced to answer hint at a darker reality beneath the surface.

    The central conflict emerges as the triplets begin to question the motives behind their separation. Why were they split up? Who made the decision? As they dig deeper into their past, they encounter resistance from the agencies and individuals involved in their adoptions. The documentary builds tension through interviews with the triplets, archival footage, and the reactions of their adoptive parents. The narrative suggests that their reunion was not merely a coincidence but part of a larger, hidden experiment. The triplets' relationship with each other deepens, yet they also begin to drift apart as the weight of the secret they suspect grows heavier. The film masterfully balances the charm of the triplets' friendship with an underlying dread, leaving the audience wondering what dark truth lies buried in their shared history.

    Ending ExplainedSpoilers

    Trailers

    Official Trailer

    Teaser

    TV Spot

    Critical Reception

    Critical Consensus

    Critics universally praised Three Identical Strangers for its masterful storytelling, emotional depth, and shocking revelations. Reviewers highlighted the film's ability to balance the initial wonder of the triplets' reunion with a mounting sense of dread as the dark truth of the experiment is unveiled. The documentary is celebrated for its investigative journalism, compelling character work, and its profound exploration of nature versus nurture.

    Top Cast

    David Kellman

    David Kellman

    Self

    Robert Shafran

    Robert Shafran

    Self

    Eddy Galland

    Eddy Galland

    Self

    Lawrence Wright

    Lawrence Wright

    Self

    Annabel Wigram

    Annabel Wigram

    Herself

    Tim Wardle

    Tim Wardle

    Himself

    Crew

    Director

    Tim Wardle

    Writer

    Tim Wardle

    Composer

    Paul Saunderson

    Cinematographer

    Tim Cragg

    Producers

    Grace Hughes-Hallett, Becky Read, Annabel Wigram, Simon Chinn, James Gay-Rees

    Awards

    Sundance Film Festival (2018)

    U.S. Documentary Directing Award: Won

    Sundance Film Festival (2018)

    U.S. Documentary Editing Award: Won

    BAFTA Awards (2019)

    Best British Film: Nominated

    BAFTA Awards (2019)

    Best Documentary: Nominated

    Emmy Awards (2019)

    Outstanding Documentary or Nonfiction Special: Nominated

    Keywords

    adoptiontwinstripletmental illnessadoptedshockingnature vs nurtureseparated at birthintrospectiveintensebewildereddistressing

    Sources

    Facts

    Discovery
    The triplets met by chance in 1980 when Bobby Shafran saw Eddy Galland in a newspaper photo and recognized him as his twin. They later found David Kellman through a mutual friend.
    Dr. Neubauer
    The scientist behind the experiment, Peter Neubauer, died in 1988, before the triplets' reunion became public knowledge. His files were sealed until the documentary's production.
    Media Frenzy
    At the height of their fame, the triplets appeared on The Tonight Show Starring Johnny Carson, Good Morning America, and 60 Minutes. They were even featured on the cover of Time magazine.
    Eddy's Suicide
    Eddy Galland's suicide in 1995 was a pivotal moment that led to the investigation into the experiment. His death was ruled a suicide, but the triplets and their families have long suspected the stress of the media attention and the revelation of the experiment played a role.
    Ben Stiller Series
    In 2023, Ben Stiller was in talks to star in a limited series adaptation of the story for Sony Pictures Television, though no further updates have been confirmed.
    Archival Footage
    The film relies heavily on archival footage, including home movies of the triplets as children, news clips from the 1980s, and interviews with the triplets' adoptive parents.
    Title Origin
    The title Three Identical Strangers refers to the triplets' initial state of being strangers who turned out to be identical.

    Join the community

    fans discussing