“Some people are bigger schmucks than others. The movie has a sweet center, but it's surrounded by too much frantic comedy.”
Roger Ebert
RogerEbert.com

United States"Takes one to know one."
User Score
1,956 votes
Tim Conrad, a rising executive at a financial firm, faces an unusual career dilemma. His boss hosts a monthly dinner where executives compete to bring the most ridiculous guest, and the winner gets a promotion. Tim wants no part of it, but a chance encounter with Barry, a sweet-natured but socially disastrous IRS employee who creates dioramas from stuffed mice, changes everything. Directed by Jay Roach (Austin Powers, Meet the Parents), this 2010 comedy stars Paul Rudd as Tim and Steve Carell as Barry, with Stephanie Szostak, Jemaine Clement, and Zach Galifianakis in supporting roles.
The film is a remake of the 1998 French comedy Le Dîner de Cons, written and directed by Francis Veber. Roach's version was penned by David Guion and Michael Handelman, with Jon Vitti also contributing. Produced on a $69 million budget, it grossed $86 million worldwide, a modest return that reflected its mixed critical reception. Critics praised Carell's committed performance but found the tone uneven, swinging between slapstick and sentiment. The film has since gained a cult following, with many appreciating its absurdist humor and the chemistry between Rudd and Carell.
Availability and pricing can change. Confirm on the provider's site before purchasing.
Tim Conrad (Paul Rudd) is on the fast track at a Los Angeles financial firm, with a beautiful girlfriend, Julie (Stephanie Szostak), and a promising career. His boss, Lance Fender (Bruce Greenwood), reveals the company's tradition: a monthly dinner where executives bring the most eccentric guest they can find, and the winner gets a significant career boost. Tim initially refuses to participate, but after a coworker is fired, he reluctantly agrees to play the game.
Tim's life takes a chaotic turn when he accidentally rear-ends Barry Speck (Steve Carell), a kind-hearted IRS employee who builds elaborate dioramas featuring taxidermied mice reenacting historical scenes. Barry, oblivious to his own social ineptitude, latches onto Tim as a friend and begins to wreak havoc on Tim's professional and personal life. Meanwhile, Tim's rival, Kieran Vollard (Jemaine Clement), plans to bring Therman (Zach Galifianakis), a self-proclaimed mind-control expert, to the dinner.
As the dinner approaches, Tim finds himself increasingly entangled in Barry's world. Barry shows up uninvited at Tim's office, meets Julie, and offers disastrous relationship advice. He also introduces Tim to his volatile friend Darla (Lucy Punch), who believes Barry is her boyfriend. Tim struggles with his conscience as he genuinely likes Barry and questions the morality of humiliating him for career gain. The tension builds as the dinner date nears, and Tim must decide whether to go through with the cruel plan or stand up for his new friend.
Trailer
Critical Consensus
Steve Carell's committed performance elevates this remake, but the film's tonal shifts and lack of the original's sharp edge keep it from reaching its potential. It's a mixed bag that offers some laughs but fails to fully deliver.
“Some people are bigger schmucks than others. The movie has a sweet center, but it's surrounded by too much frantic comedy.”
Roger Ebert
RogerEbert.com
“Steve Carell's comedy stock-price takes a terrible knock with this buttock-clenchingly bad film, a deeply unfunny pseudo-French farce.”
Peter Bradshaw
The Guardian
“The original French film on which it is based was meaner and funnier than this American remake.”
CNN
CNN
“A group of LA financiers meet regularly for dinner, each bringing along an idiot for everyone's amusement. The one with the best idiot wins.”
Slate
Slate
Director
Jay Roach
Writers
David Guion, Michael Handelman, Francis Veber, Jon Vitti
Composer
Theodore Shapiro
Cinematographer
Jim Denault
Producers
Jay Roach, Walter F. Parkes, Laurie MacDonald
Join the community
fans discussing