“Arsenic and Old Lace is undoubtedly one of the wackiest Cary Grant films ever made.”
Plugged In
Plugged In

United States"Love is blind, but murder is a family affair."
Mortimer Brewster, a drama critic who has built his career on mocking the institution of marriage, finds himself suddenly smitten with Elaine Harper, the minister's daughter. On Halloween, they impulsively tie the knot, and Mortimer, ever the cynic, decides to break the news to his beloved aunts, Abby and Martha, at their Brooklyn home. But his visit takes a macabre turn when he discovers a corpse hidden in the window seat. The sweet old ladies, it turns out, have been poisoning lonely bachelors with elderberry wine laced with arsenic, and their brother Teddy, who believes he's Theodore Roosevelt, has been burying the bodies in the cellar.
Directed by Frank Capra, this 1944 black comedy stars Cary Grant in one of his most frantic roles, a man whose carefully ordered world collapses into chaos. Josephine Hull and Jean Adair reprise their Broadway roles as the cheerfully homicidal aunts, while Raymond Massey and Peter Lorre add menace as Mortimer's escaped convict brother and his plastic surgeon accomplice. Produced by Warner Bros. on a budget of $1,120,175, the film was shot in just eight weeks to accommodate the actresses' stage commitments. It became a box office hit and remains a cornerstone of the screwball comedy genre, blending dark humor with Capra's signature warmth.
Mortimer Brewster, a successful drama critic and outspoken opponent of marriage, has just married Elaine Harper, the daughter of a local minister, on Halloween. He stops by his aunts' Brooklyn home to share the news, but his visit quickly spirals into madness. He finds a body in the window seat, and his gentle aunts, Abby and Martha, confess to poisoning lonely old men with elderberry wine, believing they are performing a mercy. Their brother Teddy, who thinks he's Theodore Roosevelt, has been burying the victims in the cellar, convinced he's digging the Panama Canal.
Mortimer, horrified, tries to get Teddy committed to a sanitarium, but his plans are complicated by the arrival of his other brother, Jonathan, a disfigured criminal on the run with his accomplice, Dr. Einstein. Jonathan has a history of violence, including tormenting Mortimer as a child, and he brings a fresh corpse of his own. The household descends into chaos as Mortimer attempts to hide the bodies, deal with the police, and protect Elaine from the truth.
As the night progresses, Mortimer's attempts to maintain normalcy fail spectacularly. Lieutenant Rooney and Officer O'Hara stumble upon the Brewster household, and the body count mounts. Mortimer's aunts continue their deadly hospitality, offering wine to any new visitor, while Jonathan plots to dispose of Mortimer and take over the house. Mortimer, desperate, must navigate a web of lies, delusions, and murder, all while trying to keep his new marriage intact.
Arsenic and Old Lace (1944) - Trailer
Arsenic and Old Lace Modern Trailer
Critical Consensus
A delightfully dark screwball comedy, Arsenic and Old Lace showcases Frank Capra's directorial flair and Cary Grant's comedic genius in a story about two sweet aunts with a murderous hobby.
“Arsenic and Old Lace is undoubtedly one of the wackiest Cary Grant films ever made.”
Plugged In
Plugged In
“Frank Capra's Arsenic and Old Lace introduces itself as a Hallowe'en tale set in Brooklyn before unrolling one of 1940s Hollywood's most frantic and surprising comedies.”
Charles Dennis
PopMatters
“Arsenic and Old Lace offers a straightforward adaptation of Joseph Kesselring's popular Broadway play.”
Deep Focus Review
Deep Focus Review
Director
Frank Capra
Writers
Joseph Kesselring, Julius J. Epstein, Philip G. Epstein
Composers
Max Steiner, Leo F. Forbstein
Cinematographer
Sol Polito
Producers
Frank Capra, Jack L. Warner
Join the community
fans discussing