Every Time I Die

Every Time I Die was an American metalcore band from Buffalo, New York, formed in 1998. For most of the band's career, the line-up was centred on brothers Keith (vocals) and Jordan Buckley (guitar), as well as rhythm guitarist Andy Williams, with bassist Stephen Micciche also being in the band for a cumulative 15 of the band's 24 years. After spending the first decade of their career on the Ferret Music label, they signed with Epitaph Records in 2008 and remained there until their split in early 2022.

The group garnered acclaim for their energetic and intense live shows, as well as their constantly evolving sound. Kerrang! noted that the band "shaped the cutting edge of modern metalcore." Their legacy includes nine studio albums and a unique crossover appeal that extended into professional wrestling through founding member Andy Williams. [edit]

The band took root in Buffalo, New York, in 1998 when brothers Keith and Jordan Buckley joined forces with Andy Williams. They spent the first decade of their career on the Ferret Music label, building a reputation through constant touring and a distinct blend of hardcore punk and metalcore. In 2008, they signed with Epitaph Records, where they remained until their split in 2022. The band is widely recognized for shaping the evolution of modern metalcore.

Early lineups saw several changes before settling into a more stable configuration. Josh Scogin served as vocalist from 2006 to 2011, bringing a different vocal dynamic before Keith returned. Stephen Micciche joined in 2005 and remained until the band's dissolution in 2022, contributing to fifteen of the band's twenty-four years together. The band released nine studio albums before disbanding in early 2022 following the release of their final album, Radical, in October 2021. [edit]

Every Time I Die was celebrated for a constantly evolving sound that refused to stay static. Their debut The Great Fire (2002) and New Junk Aesthetic (2004) established a raw, chaotic mix of hardcore punk and metalcore, characterized by Keith Buckley's aggressive screams and rapid tempo shifts. With You're Welcome (2008) and Live in London (2009), the band refined their sound, incorporating more melodic elements while maintaining heaviness.

Later albums like No One Got Left Behind (2012) and What You Fight For (2014) demonstrated a matured, dynamic range, blending technical precision with emotional depth. Death of a Dead Day (2017) and Radical (2021) continued this trajectory, featuring complex structures and introspective lyrics, solidifying their status as innovators. [edit]

Every Time I Die influenced the metalcore scene significantly, bridging the gap between hardcore punk and heavy metal. Their dual legacy with Andy Williams in professional wrestling further cemented their place in pop culture, creating a unique crossover between music and sports entertainment. Tributes poured in from across the music and wrestling worlds after Williams passed away in September 2026, including a special performance by My Chemical Romance dedicating their song "The Light Behind Your Eyes" to him for the first time live. [edit]

The fanbase, known as "Diehards," is renowned for high-energy mosh pits, crowd surfing, and vocal participation during live shows. While no official lightstick was ever produced, fans used custom lighters and glow sticks. The community remains tight-knit, often gathering to celebrate the band's discography and the unique dual careers of members like Andy Williams. [edit]

Andy Williams performed professionally as "The Butcher" in All Elite Wrestling (AEW) and other promotions., The band's name comes from a line in the song "The Great Fire" by the band Atreyu., Keith Buckley's vocal style ranged from screaming to clean singing, showcasing his versatility., Despite their success, they remained independent-minded, often handling their own merchandise and tour logistics., The band was known for their chaotic and unpredictable live shows, often featuring extended improvisation.[edit]