“While the premise is undeniably fascinating, Alcatraz struggles to find its footing between a police procedural and a time-travel drama, resulting in a show that feels both promising and undercooked.”
A.O. Scott
Vulture

United States"Thirty-two vanished fifty years ago. Now they are back."
User Score
32,000 votes
FOX launched a high-stakes mystery in January 2012 when creators Elizabeth Sarnoff, Steven Lilien, and Bryan Wynbrandt introduced Alcatraz. The series blended sci-fi elements with gritty police procedural drama to explore a bizarre event where every prisoner held at the San Francisco island facility vanished without a trace fifty years ago. Now they have returned, and the clock is ticking.
Sarah Jones led the investigation as Detective Rebecca Madsen, joined by Sam Neill as the enigmatic warden Emerson Hauser and Jorge Garcia as Dr. Diego Soto. The show ran for one season totaling thirteen episodes before cancellation in March of that same year. Critics noted the strong performances but found the pacing uneven. The project aimed for a tense atmosphere filled with suspense rather than simple action sequences.
Availability and pricing can change. Confirm on the provider's site before purchasing.
The narrative begins on January 12, 1963, when the Federal Penitentiary on Alcatraz Island empties its cells completely. Thirty-four inmates and one guard disappear into thin air, leaving behind only their belongings and a facility that remains silent for half a century. On January 12, 2012, exactly fifty years later, these individuals reappear in San Francisco. They possess no memory of the intervening time yet carry knowledge of events that have already occurred in their original timeline. Detective Rebecca Madsen discovers this pattern while investigating a series of crimes committed by men who should have been dead or incarcerated for decades.
Madsen teams up with Emerson Hauser, the former warden who appears unchanged from 1963. Hauser claims to work for a secret government division monitoring the temporal anomaly. Their partnership involves tracking down escaped convicts like Richard Webb, who are hunted by a shadowy organization known as The Syndicate. The show operates as a hybrid format where each episode features a specific criminal from the past committing a crime in the present day. This structure allows the writers to explore individual redemption arcs while maintaining a serialized mystery about the nature of the disappearance.
The central tension arises from the instability of the return. Characters realize that the timeline is fragile and that the Syndicate wants to prevent any changes to history. Dr. Diego Soto provides medical analysis suggesting a scientific cause rather than a supernatural one. The narrative builds toward a confrontation at the prison site where the portal mechanism resides. Throughout the season, the characters navigate a world where the past and present collide, dealing with the psychological trauma of losing fifty years of life. The story explores themes of redemption and the consequences of past actions against the backdrop of modern San Francisco.
Season 1 focuses heavily on establishing the rules of this time displacement. The audience learns that the prisoners were never meant to come back; their return was an accident caused by a malfunction in the time portal intended to send them forward to a safe timeline. The showrunner Elizabeth Sarnoff crafted a world where every clue leads deeper into a conspiracy involving the U.S. government. The series ends without resolving the ultimate fate of the prisoners or the full extent of the government plot due to the show's cancellation.
Official Trailer
Critical Consensus
Critics praised the strong performances of Sam Neill and Sarah Jones, noting the show's atmospheric tension and compelling mystery premise. However, many felt the pacing was uneven and the sci-fi elements lacked the depth of similar genre entries like Lost. While the concept of the vanished prisoners was intriguing, the execution often relied too heavily on procedural tropes, leading to a mixed reception that acknowledged potential but criticized its failure to sustain momentum.
“While the premise is undeniably fascinating, Alcatraz struggles to find its footing between a police procedural and a time-travel drama, resulting in a show that feels both promising and undercooked.”
A.O. Scott
Vulture
“Sam Neill brings a gravitas to the role of Warden Hauser that anchors the show, even when the script falters in its attempt to explain the complex time-travel mechanics.”
Tim Goodman
The Hollywood Reporter
“There is a certain charm to the mystery, but the show suffers from a lack of urgency and a convoluted plot that keeps viewers guessing in the wrong ways.”
Brian Lowry
Variety
Directors
Gwyneth Horder-Payton, Paul McGuigan, Bryan Burk, J.J. Abrams
Writers
Elizabeth Sarnoff, Steven Lilien, Bryan Wynbrandt, Jeff Pinkner, Jack Bender
Composer
Christophe Beck
Cinematographers
Peter Steinkamp, Michael Fimognari
Producers
Bryan Burk, J.J. Abrams, Elizabeth Sarnoff, Bryan Wynbrandt, Steven Lilien
Saturn Awards (2013)
Best Network Television Series: Nominated
Teen Choice Awards (2012)
Choice Sci-Fi/Fantasy TV Actor: Nominated
People's Choice Awards (2013)
Favorite New TV Drama: Nominated
Hugo Awards (2013)
Best Dramatic Presentation, Short Form: Nominated
Join the community
fans discussing